Friday, November 20, 2026

Frank W. Benson: Duck Stamp

Frank W. Benson's etching "Duck Stamp Design"
and the actual stamp below 

"In his later years, Frank W. Benson turned much of his attention to the conservation of birds. One of his favorite organizations was the Essex County Ornithological Club. Beginning in 1919 and continuing through 1938, the club published a yearly bulletin, in which Benson was able to fulfill his boyhood wish - to be an illustrator of ornithological texts. He also served as its president for 18 years. 

In 1916, the same year the Ornithological Club was founded, the governments of Canada and America, alarmed at the plummeting numbers of many bird species, held a Convention for the Protection of Migratory Game Birds. This was a culmination of years of conservation efforts by many fine organizations, a number of which Benson supported with his membership, donations, and hours of volunteer work.  

The government was equally committed to the creation of wildlife refuges and the restoration of wetlands. In 1934, President Roosevelt signed the Migratory Bird Hunting Stamp Act that required all waterfowl hunters to purchase a stamp, popularly known as the Duck Stamp. The revenue generated was earmarked for the buying and leasing of waterfowl sanctuaries and the restoration of wetlands. 

When Benson was asked to design the second stamp, he quickly accepted the request and donated a wash drawing of three canvasbacks above a marsh. The design was adapted for the stamps that sold for one dollar. A few years later the owners of the venerable sporting goods store, Abercrombie & Fitch, convinced Benson to produce an etching of his design for the stamp. The resulting work, 'Duck Stamp Design,' was done in 1942 in a limited edition of only one hundred prints. Today, Benson's 1935 federal duck stamp is the rarest issue among collectors. From time to time the etching, framed together with the stamp, comes up at auction fetching a price in excess of $5,000.

As of 1995, Federal Stamps have generated $501 million that have been used to preserve 4,389,792 acres of waterfowl habitat in the united States alone. Many of the more than 510 national wildlife refuges have been paid for all or in part by Duck Stamp money. Benson would have been proud."

To be continued

(Excerpts from "The Sporting Art of Frank W. Benson" by Faith Andrews Bedford.)

 

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Frank W. Benson: Canoes

"Indian Guide" by Frank W. Benson
"Frank W. Benson found the subject of canoes fascinating and had obviously watched them being made. An English writer who visited him in his Boston studio recalled, 

'We fell to talking of the birch bark canoes made by the Indians and which were no longer obtainable. He began to tell me how they made the preparation, of seasoning the different types of bark used in parts of the wood, the special grain of the woods selected for the stretchers and the peculiar method of binding which is adopted by the old Indians for the winding of the hide thongs, and the quality of the paddle. All these facts and many others were at his finger ends and I became so interested as he, with a pencil in hand, showed me the various 'tricks' of a perfect canoe, that two hours had passed most agreeably and other things had been quite forgotten.'

The skill of Benson's guides at making canoes for special purposes greatly interested him. The low-ended short canoes were best for a portage and best for paddling beneath overhanging branches. For holding a course across a wide lake with strong winds, the Indians built canoes with a narrow bow and stern and a V-sided, straight bottom. With their delicate thwarts, smooth ribs and planking covered in a taut skin of birch bark of various hues, these vessels were as much pieces of elegant sculpture as practical boats.

Benson often painted the canoes themselves. In one watercolor, 'Gaspé Boats,' the two canoes, poles resting on their gunwales, are tethered to a fallen log at the very bottom of the painting. The pattern of those three elements are like rays emanating from the lower edge of the canvas. In another small watercolor, 'The Flying Eddy,' the river, with its reflected border of trees, is the dominant element in the painting; the boat itself is almost an accent. And yet, in this quiet scene of a canoe with a rod arched over the bow, there is a sense of anticipation. The boat will soon be swirling down rapids loaded with an eager fisherman, poled by a sure-handed guide.

Shortly after selling a painting to William Wheelock, a friend who was a shooting companion as well as a major collector of his work, Benson was invited to Wheelock's home to see the canvas hanging. Benson spent the night and the following morning had breakfast in the dining room, which contained a number of his sporting works. Placing his napkin in his lap, he looked around the room and said, 'You know, William, I'm not accustomed to eating scrambled eggs and bacon in my studio!'

Wheelock laughed and asked Benson to tell him the stories of the creation of the various works. Benson regaled his hosts with descriptions of each painting location and just who was depicted. 'And who is that Indian?' asked Wheelock pointing to 'The Indian Guide.' 'That's Quonah,' said Benson, 'and the dog is Skookum.'"

To be continued

(Excerpts from "The Sporting Art of Frank W. Benson" by Faith Andrews Bedford.)

 

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Frank W. Benson: Gray Days

"Crows in the Rain" by Frank W. Benson
"A few of Frank W. Benson's trips were taken at a doctor's insistence brought about by Benson's tendency to work himself into a state of exhaustion. He was instructed to do no work during these enforced periods of rest, and it would seem that he reluctantly agreed. However, numerous paintings exist that suggest a view seen through a lodge window, 'Crows in the Rain' being one. 'Picture making has become to me merely the arrangement of design within the frame,' Benson once said. This painting of rain-soaked crows on a branch is a clear illustration of what he meant when he added, 'It has nothing to do with the painting of objects or the representation of nature. You must make your plan from the beginning and put down on your canvas the lights and darks, the line and directions that indicate that plan so that it shows from the start that it is good. Everyone has to discover for himself that this is the one essential fact of a good picture. I can remember when I discovered it for myself, and it transformed everything.'

Frank W. Benson could be hard on himself. His perfectionism sometimes sank him into bouts of low spirits that were undoubtedly exacerbated by fatigue. As he once wrote to his daughter Eleanor when she was learning to paint, 'Of course you can't paint all day and do well... You will inevitably get stale in your work and lose interest in your subject when the work doesn't go well... I have miserable days over my work when I don't want to speak to anyone. That is because you tire your faculties trying to coordinate things and they look worse than they really are.'

His inability to 'get it the way I want it' sometimes drove him to the brink of despair. Oils destroyed or painted over, etchings abandoned after only two or three trials, watercolors wadded up and flung into a wastebasket - his grandchildren could recall the frustrations at what he considered his failures. They clearly remember his coming to the lunch table in North Haven after a morning in the studio. 'He would sit there with his great head sunk in his big hands and just stare at his food,' recalls his granddaughter. These periods were so uncharacteristic that they confused the children. But their quizzical looks would only be met with their grandmother's murmured, 'Hush, children, Papa's painting is not going well.' As his frustration with his work deepened his spirits sank, and his gray mood could go on for days. 'Then,' continues his granddaughter, 'All of a sudden, he would come to dinner beaming. It was as though the sun had come out after a week of rain.'"

To be continued

(Excerpts from "The Sporting Art of Frank W. Benson" by Faith Andrews Bedford.)

 

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Frank W. Benson: What Interests Me Most

"Sunlight" by Frank W. Benson
"Frank W. Benson remembered well the lessons of nature that he learned from Abbott Thayer. His eye, trained over decades of careful observation, was often able to spot birds that his companions could not see. But, more important, it enabled him to paint them. From a grouse concealed in autumnal foliage to the colors in a Rocky Mountain peak, he concentrated on the details. That was one of the secrets to painting, one he tried to impart to his last pupil, his own daughter, Eleanor.

'The trouble with you is that like most beginners you try to embrace too wide a scene,' he once said in a moment of frustration at his inability to teach Eleanor all that he had learned over fifty years of painting. 'You are looking for the sort of scenery that a photographer would look for with lots of sky and distant hills. Be broad-minded and don't go out with a predetermined notion of what you want to find to paint. Intimate studies of light and shadow in a small area are most interesting. A thing to be beautiful must be complicated. Don't paint something just because it is simple. It's just like a tailored suit - the thing must be subtle in order to be good. The fine distinctions of value where one object comes against another are what make a picture interesting.'

He then recalled for Eleanor a time when John Singer Sargent went to Chocorua, New Hampshire at the base of the White Mountains to visit a fellow artist, Billy James. When the two went out to paint, Billy  took Sargent to the 'town view,' a mountain reflected in the lake.

Benson told Eleanor that Billy 'asked Sargent if he thought he could find anything round there to paint. Sargent said, yes, he could find something anywhere, looked around him, and sat down and painted an old gnarled root with some leaves and branches on it. What interested him was the delicate play of light and shadows on the leaves and trunk.' And that, Benson stressed to Eleanor, 'is what interests me. And should interest you.'

To be continued

(Excerpts from "The Sporting Art of Frank W. Benson" by Faith Andrews Bedford.)

Monday, November 16, 2026

Frank W. Benson: The Bahamas

"Sea Grape Trees" by Frank W. Benson
"In December of 1922, Frank W. Benson traveled to Washington at the invitation of his good friend, C. Powell Minnigerode, the director of the Corcoran Gallery of Art, to attend the opening of an exhibition of some of his black-and-white wash drawings. While these had been praised by the critics and were selling very well, their reception was eclipsed by the technicolor watercolors that Benson decided to slip into the show at the last minute.

The show at the Corcoran drew an enormous number of visitors to the galleries. On the last day, Minnigerode wrote to Benson that more than three thousand people crowded in to see the pictures before they were taken down. By the time the show closed, Minnigerode had sold all but one of the wash drawings and watercolors and was eagerly planning for another show of Benson's watercolors the following June.

Perhaps it was the phenomenal sale that prompted the Bensons to take a trip to the Bahamas that winter. Intrigued by the turquoise waters, exotic flora, and village scenes, Benson continued his watercolor painting and wrote to Minnigerode that he would have plenty of watercolors for the June show. 'When one is living in mid-summer weather with coconut palms and banana trees waving outside the windows, it is hard to write letters or to believe in winter,' Benson said. The air was so brilliant and the colors so intense that he told Minnigerode that to view them 'you will need to wear smoked glasses.'

In all he brought home thirty-five watercolors of the islands and its landscape. Aquamarine water sparkled behind scenes of gnarled sea grape trees, and native people lounged against tumble-down docks. Theses were not the scenes of a Canadian salmon river that had prompted him to first take up watercolors, but they were just as popular. By May first, when a one-man show of his Bahaman paintings opened at the Guild of Boston Artists, nine of them had already been sold.

At the close of the Guild show, only a few watercolors remained. Benson had promised to send the whole group to Minnigerode for his June watercolor show at the Corcoran and was embarrassed that his supply was so depleted. He promised that he would work hard to produce enough for a good showing in Washington. 'Don't be discouraged,' he wrote, 'I have just been fishing on Cape Cod and, besides the trout I caught, in four days I made four watercolors.' A month later he wrote of another fishing trip, 'I got 60 trout and four watercolors.' He was able to supply Minnigerode with enough work for the June exhibition - just barely. By the show's end, all had been sold, and he wrote him again with some dismay, 'I am beginning to doubt if I can keep up with the procession.'" 

To be continued

(Excerpts from "The Sporting Art of Frank W. Benson" by Faith Andrews Bedford.)

 

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Frank W. Benson: New Frontiers

"Portrait of Willard Metcalf"
by Frank W. Benson
"Frank W. Benson first discovered salmon fishing when a friend invited him to go to New Brunswick in the late summer of 1894. Accompanied by seven Indian guides, the two pushed into the wilderness for thirty miles. They poled and paddled their canoes up rapid rivers, fished numerous pools, and lived in a tent for a week. 'It was a charming experience in every way,' Benson wrote. 'The only real camp life I ever had.' As sure as the salmon he sought on his first fishing trip to Canada, Benson was hooked. His annual summer trip to the banks of the Gaspé's rivers became an important part of his life for close to four decades. As he once wrote to a friend of these trips, 'It is the thing I look forward to most during the rest of the year and, in the course of my life, I have fished and canoed on ten or twelve of the wild streams of Canada.' 

It was at the Bon Salmon Club on the Bonaventure River on Quebec's Gaspé Peninsula that another new chapter opened in Benson's life. Painted on July 19, 1921, 'Malin Run,' a study of one of the streams near the club, was the first effort by Benson in a series of watercolors that eventually numbered over 600. His second watercolor was a light, informal study of Willard Metcalf [pictured above], perched on the edge of the stream working on a small watercolor. While still in Canada, Benson painted watercolors of a guide in a canoe, one of a good fishing hole, and the salmon camp itself. Back in North Haven, he painted watercolors of a  tent, an arrangement of flowers from his wife's garden, a study of daughter Sylvia standing on a bluff gazing out to ear, a duck blind and the nearby woods, the ponds, and the autumn colors.

When a small collection of his new watercolors hung at the Guild of Boston Artists that autumn, William Howe Downes, the dean of the Boston art critics, wrote that they were suggestive of Sargent or Homer. His new direction continued to provoke glowing praise in the media. Benson was clearly encouraged by the positive reception to his new medium and wrote, 'It certainly is very heartening when you do something in a new way to find that other people are pleased with it. It makes life much more fun than it was before.'" 

To be continued

(Excerpts from "The Sporting Art of Frank W. Benson" by Faith Andrews Bedford.)

 

Friday, November 13, 2026

Frank W. Benson: "The Guild of Boston Artists" by R.H. Ives Gammell

"Reverie" by Edmund Tarbell,
first president of the Guild of Boston Artists
We have just read about the formation of the Guild of Boston Artists, with Frank W. Benson being one of its founders and its second president. It has also been brought to my attention that it was NOT begun as a reaction to any discrimination from out-of-state exhibitions but for very different reasons. The following excerpt from a paper written by R.H. Ives Gammell explains its beginnings.

THE GUILD OF BOSTON ARTISTS

BY R. H. IVES GAMMELL 

1942

 

"TWENTY-EIGHT YEARS AGO a group of artists working in Boston decided to form a professional group which they would call the Guild of Boston Artists. The primary purpose of this move was to enable these painters and sculptors to maintain a gallery of their own in which they could exhibit their work. Expenses ‘were to be met by deducting a percentage from the sales made in the gallery, by dues from the active members, and through a group of associate members as well. For active membership there was to be one essential qualification, the professional competence of an artist in his particular field. To be a member of the Guild of Boston Artists a painter or a sculptor. must know his trade. This, at least, was the intention of the founders.

 

That was in 1914. The concept of making professional knowledge and skill the common denominator for an association of artists seemed then, less eccentric and subversive than it would seem to many people today. It was, in point of fact, merely trying to do in Boston what had been done in Europe for several hundred years, wherever artists congregated in sufficient numbers. Organized first as confraternities or guilds, later as academies, these groups of professional workers in the arts had always tried to maintain certain standards of craftsmanship as well as to cooperate for their own mutual protection and advancement. Conditions in twentieth century Boston were very different from those which had made the earlier guilds necessary in their day. It would have been impossible to pattern the new institution after its predecessors. But the name made an appeal to the organizers because of its association with high professional standards. And it was to the painter’s guilds of seventeenth-century Holland that the founders of the Guild of Boston Artists looked with the greatest sympathy." *

 

* If you would like a pdf of the entire essay, click here.